Thursday, November 19, 2026

BELONGING - TO WHOM AND TO WHAT - PART 2

 




A FAMILY UNDER CONSTANT THREAT AND FEAR


We are all aware of the assassination of Mrs. Indira Gandhi and Mr. Rajiv Gandhi.

We also remember the incident where a soldier hit Rajiv with his gun while Rajiv was inspecting a parade in Sri Lanka.

Some other incidents have faded our of memory and some have not been reported.

These are brought out in the memoir of Mrs. Sonia #BELONGING.

But, even before her assassination, Mrs. Gandhi had been under constant fear that anything could happen to her. Reasons are multifarious.

She had perceived that the entire agitation in Gujarat and later in Bihar were with the only motive to unseat her. She had felt that those who could not get to power through elections were trying to create chaos and anarchy. Typically, what the present-day rulers at Delhi also feel and proclaim. And being under constant fear about her own feet on the ground, within the party, since most of other leaders were far more seniors to her, naturally, she was constantly under political fear.

The litigation in the Allahabad High Court against her election by Raj Narain also was seen only as a result of frustration. And when the High Court quashed her election on grounds of corruption, mainly for utilizing the services of a serving IAS officer for her electioneering, as Sonia would mention in the memoir, it was seen only as a mere technicality which really could not have mattered in the case of a Prime Minister with the support of two thirds of the MPs. (p200)

Of course, in todays perspective those technicalities pale into insignificance. I remember having read in the book by Prashanth Bushan (during my college days) regarding the proceedings before the Allahabad High Court that one of the main issues was regarding misuse of an official by name Yashpal Kapoor. He was an IAS Officer and was the Personal Secretary to Mrs. Gandhi, the PM. He submitted his resignation and proceeded to do election work for Mrs. Gandhi. During the proceedings, it was learnt that he had done election work before his resignation had been accepted. Since date of acceptance is to be treated as the actual date of resignation, his election work, just after submission of his papers but before they were accepted was held a corrupt activity and utilising his service was one main charge against the PM. When entire machinery and institutions could be misused these days, the charge of 1971 become laughable to us. But those days when people (and judiciary) expected people in high places to maintain high standards and probity.

I had also come across a rumor (those days though the Whatsapp university had not yet been installed) that the Russian President Brezhnev had asked Mrs. Gandhi how a very junior Judge appointed by her Government could unseat her. Though there are no verifiable records for such a statement to have been made, given the mind set of the Communist Government in the USSR, it gels with the pattern. For that matter, in later days to come, we have seen how the Judiciary could be at the beck and call of the Elected Executive.

It is on record that it was not as if that no carrots were shown to Judge Jag Mohan Lal Sinha who had delivered that verdict. It is on record that he was approached from Delhi and sounded that he was in line to be elevated. Also his Chief had sounded him out. The judgement had come in spite of all those efforts. But those days, it was within the confines of only luring. Not beyond.

Regarding the technicality of the judgment, it is also on record that Fali Nariman, himself was of the firm belief that the judgement, which Mrs Gandhi wanted him to personally examine to vet the grounds for her appeal, was "singularly weak in its reasoning". This sentiment was echoed by the Times, London, which described Justice Sinha's verdict disqualifying Mrs Gandhi for six years on account of the length of a rostrum as "firing the Prime Minister for a traffic ticket".

It is another matter that after the proclamation of the Emergency all hell was let lose and what hooliganism by Police and in the name of Police is seen in the present day could be seen performed those days, which then was a shock to a nation that had woken up to freedom only 3 decades ago.

So, the family of the PM was under the firm belief that all that had happened was only a part of the conspiracy by the opposition. That the RSS had joined hands with JP was also a fact and added to their fear. (p195) We can understand this fear, for, as seen in the case of the assassination of Gandhiji, one could never estimate from where an RSS man could emerge to perform his pre meditated ‘karthavya’, whether self-motivated or organised.

Mrs. Gandhi was also having the fear that some bigger players were involved in the entire episode who were not happy with her for her role in the liberation of Bangladesh and explosion of nuclear device and that they saw her as being too independent and defiant. (p201)

The assassination of Mujibur Rahman in Bangladesh, and his entire family including a nine-year-old boy, with only his two daughters who happened to be in West Germany on that day escaping, was another factor which sent shiver down the spine of the Indira Gandhi family. (p204) This had happened on 15th of August 1975, immediately after the proclamation of the Emergency here.

The animosity exhibited by the public after lifting of the Emergency and their defeat in 1977 is best seen in the episode when the family decided to celebrate the birth day of Rahul, as they used to do every year and made all arrangements, but none of his friends and family members turned up. (p216)

After they had shifted out of the official residence (to the house of Mohamed Yunis since they did not have a house of their own) one day suddenly a person had crept into their house unnoticed and was hiding under their dining table, with a knife in hand. Luckily the Congress workers who were working there noticed him and apprehended him. Though he was handed over to the police, he never came forward with an explanation. (p222)

There was another attempt on Mrs. Gandhi by some persons while she was on a visit to Karnataka, but was saved by Mrs. Nirmala Deshpande, a Gandhian, who threw herself bodily on Mrs. Gandhi to protect her from the blows and the presence of mind of the driver who moved the car quickly away. (p223)

After re-election in 1980:

Then came the terrorist activities of the Khalisthan and the Blue star operation.

On 24th of October 1984, the family was to assemble for Diwali. But it was learnt later that a number of grenades had been secreted away in a room next to their kitchen, intended for that very day to liquidate the assembled family, but for some unknown reason called off at the last minute. (p256) But it is strange that in spite of that, the assassination happened barely a week thereafter. We are reminded again of how an attempt previously made on Gandhiji came to light and yet came to get executed within another 10 days. While Mrs. Sonia could blame V.P.Singh and Chandrasekar for not beefing up the security for Rajiv in 1991, that the PM’s security was lax when she herself was in power is strange and is a jittery lesson for those who decide to ride a tiger.

In the same week on 30th of October, just a day prior to the assassination of Mrs. Gandhi, a car had rammed into the jeep that was escorting the children from School. Mrs. Indira Gandhi had seen it as a message, a warning. (p256)

Mrs. Gandhi’s speech at Orissa on 30th October 1984 has already been widely reported. She had said, ‘I am here today; I may not be here tomorrow. It doesn’t matter to me whether I live or die. And when I die, every drop of my blood will nourish and strengthen my Bharat”. ((p258)

But from what Rajiv later wrote to his children, it would come out clearly that what she spoke was not on a of a spur of the moment.

Rajiv wrote to his children later that he was convinced that Dadi (Mrs. Indira Gandhi) knew that she was going to die on that very day and had given indications and she prepared to leave them; and also that she had told him (Rajiv) not to cry if anything happened to her and also had given instructions about her funeral, not wanting to be cremated, but the body to be released on a glacier high up in the Kashmir snow peaks. (p257)

Further evidence regarding her premonition of the impending assassination is recorded by Mrs. Sonia when she says that when they were packing to move out of their home, a few weeks after the assassination, they found among her (Mrs. Indira Gandhi) papers a few lines jotted down seemingly in a hurry, three days after the Operation Blue Star. The note signed and dated June 11, 1984, read “If anything happens to me…no mourning of any kind. No funeral. Body to be put in a casket and thrown in a crevasse in the high Himalayas. Beautiful classical music, Indian and Western, could be played in various places, no mournful tunes”. (p269). This again confirms what Rajiv wrote to his children also.

One could imagine the shock and fear in the home when a PM was assassinated by her own body guards at her very residence.

Then it became to be shifted to Rajiv.

When Sonia pleaded with him not to accept the PM post saying that they would kill him too and that he cannot do this to them (his family), he says “They will kill me anyway”. (p261)

Considering the threat to the lives of the entire family, Gorbachev had offered to host the children of Rajiv in Russia for the duration of their schooling. (p300)

Rajiv’s attempt to douse the fire of animosities came in the form of many accords he signed. The Longowal accord was the first one and was applauded by the entire nation. But Longowal himself was assassinated on the very birth day of Rajiv. (p288)

Barely two months earlier an Air India Boeing flying from Toronto to Delhi had been blown up in mid-air, enroute to London, killing all 329 on board, which remained one of deadliest plane crash through an act of terrorism till the 9/11 attack in the US. (p288)

A month earlier transistor bombs were set off in Delhi in several places. (p288)

In August 1986, General Vaidya who had caried out the Operation Blue Star was shot dead in Pune. (p289)

On October 2nd 1987, when Rajiv went to Rajghat to pay homage to Gandhiji, an attempt was made on him by a gun man. (p345)

Again, the Sri Lankan pact brought along with it, what Rahul had forewarned Rajiv, its repercussions. (p355)

When Rajiv was inspecting the customary farewell guard of honour, a cadet of Sri Lankan Navy hit him with his rifle. Rajiv managed to move away from the strength of the blow by a fraction of a second. It was the reaction of the Sri Lankan military man against the intervention of Indian Military on their soil.

Mrs. Sonia says that there was a large bruise on the shoulder of Rajiv as a consequence of the blow a large swelling for which he took painkillers for a number of days, but the blow had been fierce and, while the pain lessened, it lingered to the end of his days. (p346)

The reaction to the Sri Lankan pact from the LTTE came to ultimately claim Rajiv’s life in the bomb blast at Sriperumpudur.

We have already seen how Rahul had to change his identity and live abroad for a very long time after the assassination of his father.

Dalai Lama had asked Mrs. Sonia, “Do you feel vengeful towards those who killed Rajiv?”. She says she said, “No, I don’t,” and burst into sobs. (p380)

Rahul was only 14 years old and Priyanka 12, when their grandmother was killed. They were only 21 and 19 when their father was assassinated.

Thinking of the shadow of death, threat and fear under which these children lived almost all their adolescent life, one could only sympathize with them.

And yet, Mrs. Sonia refused to leave India. And still some brand her a ‘foreigner’.

While talking to Rahul and Priyanka about the loss of their father, whom he so admired, Nelson Mandela told, “You must learn to turn that painful experience into a positive, because it is positivity and courage that will define all your future actions”. (p312)

Might be it was due to that advice Priyanka went to the prison to see the killers of Rajiv. Only the family has to say.

But one thing is certain. Those kids having seen what it was like to lose their loved ones to terrorism and hate and having lived under the shadow of fear and threat to their lives for such a long time, are the best ones to show the people what it is really to love.

To be continued……

 

 

Monday, November 16, 2026

BELONGING - TO WHOM AND TO WHAT? - PART -1


 

Mrs. Sonia Gandhi has been one personality who has been detested and despised by many for being a foreigner trying to ascend to the throne at Delhi and on the other hand revered by many others on par with Annie Besant and Sister Nivedita, who had left their homeland to serve India.

Before embarking upon a review of the memoir of Mrs. Sonia Gandhi – ‘Belonging A Journey of Love’ I should first place on record my impressions/opinions/prejudices about her and her family I had held based on my own understanding of the situations.

I have felt that Jawaharlal Nehru was a very intelligent and dedicated person with left leanings, but had a poetic bent of mind and hence was not a tough administrator and due to this failed in facing the situation that emanated out of the Chinese betrayal. But his yearning to build a developed Nation right from the beginning and laying the foundation for several institutions could not be surpassed till date. However, he had on the political side, allowed his daughter to dabble in party affairs as a result of which there was purging of opposition at regional levels and serious dents in democracy and federalism started developing under his very feet.

Mrs. Gandhi, her daughter had a sharp mind and regal posture that gave her a feeling that she could not be questioned; due to her being a lady in power and that too at the very top, had felt insecure at very many times and had therefore to lean upon one or the other for support, which many times were wrong decisions – like her dependence upon a very young Sanjay, Dheerandra Brahmachari, etc. However her pride for the Country could never be questioned.

Sanjay was widely known to be brash and the chief executor of the Emergency excesses and by his speed had unfortunately got killed himself. He had ideological synergy with the RSS.

Rajiv, a reluctant warrior, came in to support his mother after his brother had died, allowed himself to be anointed as the PM violating the norms of even getting elected as the CPP leader and not even being a member of the Cabinet, thereafter rode to power with a massive majority, started with a good intention, but fell into wrong company, squandered the opportunity and landed on the opposition benches. He lost his life as a consequence of an ill-timed and unprofessional pact that he signed with the President of Sri Lanka, against sage counsel. Though cleared by the courts, the issue of Bofors still is a smoking gun in the minds of the common man. His unwitting contribution to Rama Janmabhoomi as a fall out of the Shah Bano episode also is an issue which has had a bulldozer effect upon the fabric of the Nation. 

His wife, Mrs. Sonia had been waiting in the wings to take over the party and after Narasimha Rao failed to muster a majority in 1996, took control over the party and after failing to muster 272 MPs to support her after the Vajpayee Government fell (even though she had publicly stated that she had the requisite numbers) then wanted to become the PM in 2004 but due to perhaps some questions (about her nationality) raised by the then President Shri. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, she had stepped aside to make Dr. Manmohan Singh the PM. Then she was doing back seat driving for 10 years until UPA lost the elections to the BJP.

Now with her advanced age and failing health, her children are trying to claim the lost heritage.

In spite of all these, I booked my pre-booked copy of her Memoirs due to two reasons

(1) To morally support the publication of the book when it was learnt that due pressure from some powers that be, Penguin had stepped aside from publishing it in India (for such a huge publication agency to step aside, the powers exerted should have been that great)

(2) To see whether there was any material in the book that could change my already held impressions.

In this context, I am giving a review of the 506 pages of ‘BELONGING A JOURNEY OF LOVE’

Before even I got a copy of the book, I had the opportunity to see on social media comments regarding its contents. Out of those, the following appeared to be totally fabricated:

1) That she had said Vajpayee went to her after Rajiv assassination and assured of any help and she felt the relation ship to that of like with a brother. (No such mention is seen in the book)

2) That she praised Amit Shah for his bravery in the matter of Article 370 and that she is amazed at the booth level knowledge of Amit shah due to which while Modi wins hearts, Amit Shah wins elections. (Again not seen in the book- for that matter she does not even mention about Amit Shah anywhere in the book)

(If anything as stated in the social media which I did not find in the book is really there, kindly intimate in the comments box with the page number in the book so that I shall correct myself)

Now, coming to the already widely known contents:

1) Her love for Rajiv, due to which in spite of opposition and apprehensions of their family she decided to get married to him and to come to India

2) She was diligently loyal to her mother-in-Law

3) Rajiv was against imposition of Emergency and used to bring to the notice of his mother, adverse criticism he used to get from the common public while he was working as a pilot. But his mother brushed them aside.

4) Sanjay was the chief supporter of the Emergency and later he was against it being lifted.

5) Mrs. Gandhi felt that things had gone too far and lifted it in spite of opposition from Sanjay.

6) Sanjay got killed in the plane accident due to his rashness.

7) Later after his death, in spite of her stiff opposition, Rajiv stepped into the shoes of Sanjay to be of support to his mother.

Now we come to what she has said that is anything new (or not said where she was expected to throw new light):

She has furnished only the official stand of Rajiv in the Bofors issue. No mention about Ottavio Quattrocchi the Italian business man whose name got connected with the scam. The best defense she could advance perhaps is this: “In certain instances, we’d come to know that a friend had used our name to secure some gain, large or small, in a matter of which we know nothing; they’d approached persons in authority who believed it was useful to cultivate someone known to be close to the prime minister-at times with serious repercussions on Rajiv”.(p333) Though this is not stated directly with reference to the Bofors scandal, it is said in general, which appears to cover the scandal in question, indirectly. Because she also says with reference to the scandal, ‘but after a protracted series of disclosures, enquiries, accusations, and denials, it was established that indeed there had been agents-opening the door to allegations of corruption.’ (p335)

The reasons for the downfall of Rajiv she has given are as below:

He wanted to take on the power centers in the Congress which had ruffled quite a few feathers (p320)

He himself said that he was not a Political animal (p336-337)

That she felt that Rajiv was like Abhimanyu who got caught in the chakravyuka (p343)

Rahul is a child who keeps on questioning. Rahul had warned Rajiv against sending Indian forces to Sri Lanka and questioned Rajiv about the possible repercussions (p355)

Priyanka shows her steel when she stands facing a wall for more than 2 hours refusing to say sorry when Rajiv tries to punish her (p217)

After a trip from Bihar during the election campaign, before he left to US, Rahul had warned that if the security of his father is not beefed up, he may have to soon come for his funeral (p358 & 366)

When some one called Rahul over phone and said that there was bad news he asked, “Papa is dead, isn’t it’? (p368)

Rajiv had a short temper which his Mother attributed it to his Father and Mrs. Sonia adds ‘to his mother too’ (p317) typical of a mother and a daughter in law.

It was this short temper which created the embarrassment of his public statement ‘You’ll be soon talking to a new foreign secretary”, for which Rajiv later regretted saying, 'I knew the moment I’d spoken that I’d made a blunder. I wish I hadn’t opened my mouth’. (p318,319)

With regard to this book, I saw some post on the social media demanding that Sonia should apologize for the Emergency Excesses. For that matter, she was not the architect or executor of the Emergency and why she has to do that? Further she has herself recorded that Mrs. Indira Gandhi during a tour to Maharashtra (after her defeat in 1977) openly said that people were annoyed with the mistakes committed; that she accepted the verdict of the people; and that who ever has done the excesses, she accepted the responsibility’. (p221) She has also explained in detail how Rajiv was opposed to it and had asked his mother to resign after the Allahabad High Court judgement (p203)

However, regarding the reaction to the opposition, JP and others, Mrs. Sonia toes the line of Mrs. Indira Gandhi only. She also feels that there was an alround conspiracy to unseat Mrs. Indira Gandhi. This clearly shows that the family was not able to see beyond their own perspective. While it is clear that there was unrest, it is not that the only objective was to unseat her, but because the process of democracy was under pressure. The staple argument of those in power that who ever is questioning them is anti-whatever is not expected out of Mrs. Sonia Gandhi, after being in the opposition and facing the same situation for quite some time now. 

One fact that shocked me was that when both mother and son were defeated in the 1977 elections, they did not have a house to shift to. ‘Suddenly, from one day to the next, we found ourselves stranded-without a home, and with only one earning member of the family, Rajiv’. (p214). That they did not think of building their own house (when Mrs. Gandhi had already donated her ancestral home ‘Anand Bhavan’ in Allahabad) is also indicative of another fact: that mother and son never imagined that they will lose power – at least to the extent that they would not have a government accommodation. That attitude was one of the foremost ones that enraged the people then and could do so again.

The psychological trauma Priyanka and Rahul faced at school after the defeat in 1977 and animosity of the common people shown towards them is another aspect brought out in the book. (p215,216) People in power have to always remember that they may be out of it also some times and accordingly blend their behaviour. We can only sympathize with the children.

About Dhirendra Brahmachari Sonia does not record a high opinion. She calls him ‘like Narada muni’ carrying tales from one to the other and “over the years, we came to hear tales about his own wheeling and dealing” (p225)

She also records ‘a bizarre happening’ that a palmist read the hand of Rajiv and said that he and not Sanjay will become PM and that they all had a hearty laugh over the joke. (p225)

During the appearance of Mrs. Gandhi before the Allahabad High Court, suddenly the issue of Maruthi had been brought up. Mrs. Gandhi looked at Rajiv and Sonia who were among the audience and looked intently as if trying to say some thing. Since Sonia or Rajiv did not understand it, a piece of paper was sent and handed over to Rajiv where it was stated that they should not be in the Court. They left, without understanding why. Later Mrs. Gandhi told Sonia that since Sonia was one of the Directors of Maruthi, if she had suddenly been called to testify, she may have found things difficult. (p197). On one hand this shows that the mother-in-law was being protective of the daughter-in-law and on the other it also shows that something inadvertently drawn out of the mouth of Sonia would have caused damage to Sanjay since Sonia was there as a partner only for namesake.

Sonia repeatedly states that her memory of events following getting the news of Rajiv’s assassination was sketchy and she was dazed and only Priyanka was holding the fort. She says that suddenly she had an urge to see his body and said that he had donated his eye to which the doctor said, ‘Eyes? What are you talking about? There is nothing left, nothing’. (p367) A terrific thing to even imagine. Sonia says that till date she has not seen the picture of Rajiv’s remains after the explosion. (p374). And yet, how brutally people have been holding her responsible or in the know of the assassination of Rajiv.

After the assassination of Rajiv, the entire family felt threatened, Sonia’s family asked her to come away to Italy with children (p371,372), Rahul had to change his identity and live without revealing his identity (p376). But Sonia said that this was her home, her country and her children’s country and could not leave (p371).

She had after all relinquished her Italian citizenship when Rajiv became MP of Amethi (p246)

More in the next part….

 

 

 

Monday, November 9, 2026

RIGHT TO VOTE IS RIGHT TO LIFE WITH DIGNITY

 


    The Supreme Court has held that ‘Access to internet by Children is a FundamentalRight under the Constitution. 

    Right to Education itself was upheld as a Fundamental Right and made a part of Right to Life as per the Judgement of the Supreme Court long ago and accordingly inserted as Article 21A.  It was on the basis of the reasoned finding that without education (basic) a life with dignity was not possible.

    However, the 'Right to Vote' is not yet accepted as a Fundamental Right, by the Supreme Court of India till date.

 This post intends to examine the issue:

Section 62 of ‘The Representation of the People Act, 1951’ defines the Right to vote as below:

“62. Right to vote.—

(1)No person who is not, and except as expressly provided by this Act, every person who is, for the time being entered in the electoral roll of any constituency shall be entitled to vote in that constituency.

(2)No person shall vote at an election in any constituency if he is subject to any of the disqualifications referred to in section 16 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 (43 of 1950).

(3)No person shall vote at a general election in more than one constituency of the same class, and if a person votes in more than one such constituency, his votes in all such constituencies shall be void.

(4)No person shall at any election vote in the same constituency more than once, notwithstanding that his name may have been registered in the electoral roll for the constituency more than once, and if he does so vote, all his votes in that constituency shall be void.

(5)No person shall vote at any election if he is confined in a prison, whether under a sentence of imprisonment or transportation or otherwise, or is in the lawful custody of the police:

Provided that nothing in this sub-section shall apply to a person subjected to preventive detention under any law for the time being in force.

Provided further that by reason of the prohibition to vote under this sub-section, a person whose name has been entered in the electoral roll shall not cease to be an elector.

(6)Nothing contained in sub-sections (3) and (4) shall apply to a person who has been authorised to vote as proxy for an elector under this Act in so far as he votes as a proxy for such elector.”

         Now, what if a person does not have a vote, other than due to any of the exclusions in the above Section?

         The present dispute regarding the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) is a case in point.

       Though the SIR has been conducted in earlier regimes also, the present exercise has been subjected to disputes for a variety of reasons.

The statutory authority for the Election Commission to conduct a revision of the Voter List, flows out of the following provisions of ‘The Representation Of The People Act, 1950’ :

“Section 21. Preparation and revision of electoral rolls.—

(1)The electoral roll for each constituency shall be prepared in the prescribed manner by reference to the qualifying date and shall come into force immediately upon its final publication in accordance with the rules made under this Act.

(2)The said electoral roll—

(a)shall, unless otherwise directed by the Election Commission for reasons to be recorded in writing, be revised in the prescribed manner by reference to the qualifying date—(i)before each general election to the House of the People or to the Legislative Assembly of a State; and(ii)before each bye-election to fill a casual vacancy in a seat allotted to the constituency; and

(b)shall be revised in any year in the prescribed manner by reference to the qualifying date if such revision has been directed by the Election Commission:

Provided that if the electoral roll is not revised as aforesaid, the validity or continued operation of the said electoral roll shall not thereby be affected.

(3)Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (2), the Election Commission may at any time, for reasons to be recorded, direct a special revision of the electoral roll for any constituency or part of a constituency in such manner as it may think fit:

Provided that subject to the other provisions of this Act, the electoral roll for the constituency, as in force at the time of the issue of any such direction, shall continue to be in force until the completion of the special revision so directed.

 

Section 22. Correction of entries in electoral rolls.—

If the electoral registration officer for a constituency, on application made to him or on his own motion, is satisfied after such inquiry as he thinks fit, that any entry in the electoral roll of the constituency—

(a)is erroneous or defective in any particular,

(b)should be transposed to another place in the roll on the ground that the person concerned has changed his place of ordinary residence within the constituency, or

(c)should be detected on the ground that the person concerned is dead or has ceased to be ordinarily resident in the constituency or is otherwise not entitled to be registered in that roll, the electoral registration officer shall, subject to such general or special direction, if any, as may be given by the Election Commission in this behalf, amend, transpose or delete the entry after proper verification of facts in such manner as may be prescribed:

Provided that before taking any action on any ground under clause (a) or clause (b) or any action under clause (c) on the ground that the person concerned has ceased to be ordinarily resident in the constituency or that he is otherwise not entitled to be registered in the electoral roll of that constituency, the electoral registration officer shall give the person concerned a reasonable opportunity of being heard in respect of the action proposed to be taken in relation to him after proper verification of facts in such manner as may be prescribed.”

 

    The state-wise data regarding additions and deletions through the current SIR is as below (Source: https://www.newsclick.in/exclusive-sir-probe-how-many-voters-did-eci-really-disenfranchise)

 


     The investigation by the Internet Freedom foundation reveals how these ‘logicaldiscrepancies have arisen: 

“The deletions and notices do not occur evenly partly due to how the software reads names which are the data entries. The transliteration engine's failures are systematic rather than random. "Xalxo", the spelling used by the Oraon community, was rendered "Khalkho" and flagged, Md and Mohammed, Sk and Sheikh, and Chattopadhyay and Chatterjee were treated as distinct persons. Each such mismatch between an elector's name, or a parent's name, and the digitised roll surfaces either as an unmapped entry or as a logical discrepancy of the parent-name kind, and therefore as a notice.”

The Wire in its report under the heading ‘In West Bengal, SIR Hearing Notices Surgein Muslim-Majority Districts’ dated 14.01.2026, states as below:

‘..the release of the Draft Roll and Absentee, Shifted, Suspected Dead (ASSD) list sparked resentment in Matua and other Hindu Scheduled Caste localities. These communities were hit heavily by deletions and no-mapping, due to which the narrative backfired. In recent weeks, however, the administrative focus appears to have shifted, through the SIR hearing process, towards minority-heavy Polling Stations (PS).’

‘In The Wire’s earlier constituency-level reading of the SIR draft rolls, “No Mapping” emerged as a key pressure point. Voters who could not be linked to the 2002 roll, the legacy anchor in the SIR 2025 framework, were effectively pushed into a higher-risk verification pathway. But the analysis also produced an inconvenient statistical outcome for BJP’s “infiltration” propaganda. Muslim-majority constituencies appeared among the most consistently mapped and, therefore, among the most documented. In Murshidabad, for instance, Domkal (77.67% minority population) showed just 0.42% No Mapping, while Raninagar (75.40% minority) recorded 0.91%, Hariharpara (74.96% minority) 0.60%, and Lalgola (77.29% minority) 1.1%.

Yet the district-wise hearing numbers reviewed by The Wire tell a sharply different story. Across districts, the share of voters called for hearings climbs steeply with the Muslim population share. Statistical analysis of the dataset shows a strong positive correlation between a district’s Muslim population percentage and the percentage of electors called for hearing per constituency, with a correlation coefficient of 0.79. In practical terms, this implies that approximately 62% of the variation in hearing-call rates across districts can be explained by Muslim population density alone.

The implication is stark: even where Muslims appear highly “mapped” (low No Mapping), Muslim-heavy districts still show the highest hearing intensity, suggesting the system driving voters into hearings is not primarily No Mapping, but other triggers such as “logical discrepancies”, duplicates and name-related mismatches, especially those amplified by script conversion and rigid matching rules.’

In this context, the provisions of the Constitution require to be viewed:

Article 325 of the Constitution of India mandates that “there shall be one general electoral roll for every territorial constituency for elections to Parliament or State Legislatures, and no person can be excluded from or granted a special electoral roll based solely on religion, race, caste, or sex”.

Thus, any exclusion on the basis of religion, race or caste, is strictly Unconstitutional.

Now, let us come to the question of completion of the appellate proceedings under the Principles of Natural Justice.

         The appeals against deletion from the voters list is governed by the Section 24 of ‘The Representation of Peoples Act, 1950’, which reads as below:

“Section 24. Appeals.—

An appeal shall lie within such time and in such manner as may be prescribed.--(a)to the magistrate or additional district magistrate or executive magistrate or district collector or an officer of equivalent rank, from any order of the electoral registration officer under section 22 or section 23(b)to the chief electoral officer, from any order of the district magistrate or the additional district magistrate under clause (a).”

          Now, as long as the above said procedure of appeal has not been completed, the action set out in Section 22 of the said Act is not yet complete and therefore as per the Provisio to Sub Section 3 of Section 21 of the said Act, “the electoral roll for the constituency, as in force at the time of the issue of any such direction, shall continue to be in force until the completion of the special revision so directed”. 

          In respect of WB, as per The Hindu report, 38.31 lakh appeals had been filed before the tribunals as per ECI   This in spite of the ECI stating that only 27 lakhs were deleted due to ‘logical discrepancies’. 

    However as per reports by an investigation by the Internet Freedom foundation, ‘Behind the deletions lay a larger suspect population, the logical-discrepancy software flagged 1.31 crore electors in West Bengal and 2.35 crore in Madhya Pradesh, 17.11% and 41.22% of those electorates, and West Bengal's count fell to about 95 lakh within weeks as the rules were modified mid-exercise.’ 

     As per reports in the Times of India, out of the above appeals, only about 1,26,194 could be decided as in September 2026 (much after the elections have been completed in May 2026) and out of that 93% appeals have been decided in favour of the appellants and have been re-instated in the voter list. 

The remaining appeals are pending.

         Thus when the appeal proceedings are pending, the voter list could not be considered as final and therefore the voter list that existed prior to the SIR ought to have been the basis on which elections should have happened.

         But, unfortunately, in spite of a litigation before the Supreme Court, this did not happen.

    During the Bengal SIR hearings, a Supreme Court judge is reported to have remarked that even if the right to vote was taken away in this election, people wrongfully excluded could come back and vote in the future. 

         It is in this context that the question arises as to whether ‘Right to Vote’ is a Fundamental Right under the Constitution or not.  News reports state that the Supreme Court has held that it is not a Fundamental Right.

        Article 21 of the Constitution of India reads as below:

“21. Protection of life and personal liberty

No person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law.”

     In the landmark judgment Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978), Supreme Court held that the right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 is not limited to mere animal existence but includes the right to live with dignity. The court emphasized that the procedure established by law must be fair, just, and reasonable, and it cannot be arbitrary, oppressive, or unreasonable.

     In the case of Subramanian Swamy vs Union of India, (WP (CRIMINAL) No. 184 OF 2014) Supreme Court held that ‘Right to reputation is an insegregable part of Article 21 of the Constitution. A person’s reputation is an inseparable element of an individual’s personality and it cannot be allowed to be tarnished and that the right to reputation is an inherent right guaranteed by Article 21’.

     In The Cochin Institute Of Science And ... vs Jisin Jijo The Kerala High Court in its judgement dated 4 June, 2019 held that ‘the fundamental right to life under Article 21 encompasses the right of an individual to make choices and take decisions impacting the evolution of the individual.’  In doing so the High Court placed reliance upon the judgement of the Supreme Court in Puttasamy case where it had been laid down that ‘The freedoms under Article 19 can be fulfilled where the individual is entitled to decide upon his or her preferences. Read in conjunction with Article 21, liberty enables the individual to have a choice of preferences on various facets of life including what and how one will eat, the way one will dress, the faith one will espouse and a myriad other matters on which autonomy and self-determination require a choice to be made within the privacy of the mind.”

     The News Click in its report dated 22.06.2026 states as below:

“In West Bengal and Bihar alone, the state governments –elected on the basis of this faultily implemented SIR–have simply announced –without policy discussion or judicial scrutiny –that the ‘new voters lists’ will be regarded as the final electoral list and linked this to welfare programmes. Both states are now ruled by the extreme right Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), a political behemoth that has –in close collusion with a non-transparent Election Commission of India (ECI) been a “beneficiary” of this SIR process.

Put clearly, if a person’s name is removed from the voter list, their ration card is deactivated, monthly cash transfers are stopped, and even their bank accounts face cancellation. There are also local reports of the possibility of unilateral deletion from agricultural land records, especially if you are a disenfranchised voter from Murshidabad and Malda, Muslim majority districts! This policy effectively treats a deleted voter as someone who has lost their official status as a citizen without the final adjudication of their citizenship status.”

Depriving someone of the right to vote and exclusion from the voters list, could deprive them the very right to exist as a citizen and get any benefits from the Government schemes, which directly impacts their life as well as that of their children, could create a stigma in the eyes of others, as if they are illegal immigrants, as if they have fudged their records earlier, as if their exercising the right to vote earlier was by reasons of fraud or forgery or misstatement and consequently causes irreparable damage to their reputation and also the right to dignity which are enshrined in the Article 21 of the Constitution as has been upheld by the Supreme Court itself.  

Further, as pointed out by the Kerala High Court in the Jisin Jijio case, when the citizens have a right of choice under Article 21 read with Article 19, denial of the right to vote, unless as per the reasons set out in The Representation of Peoples Act, would tantamount to denial of the right to choose ones representative and as a consequence the Government and directly impacts ‘the right of an individual to make choices and take decisions impacting the evolution of the individual’.

If the Supreme Court is not able to see through these, the stature of the Highest Court would be sullied as warned by Justice V.R.Krishna Iyer as below:

"One day the people of this country will rise and say that we don't want this magnificent red stone edifice on the Curson Road because it is seen to be counterproductive and in turn the High Courts."

 

 

 

 

 

Tuesday, October 20, 2026

HAPPY DUSSERA

 



DUSSERA 2026

20.10.2026

 


O King of might!
Who walks with a thud and voice resonates with thunder,
Whose chest is so broad as to face a thousand tuskers,
Whose flashing eyes could put to shame any striking lightning,
And who with a finger raised could make the mountains crouch.


O devotee of the Lord of Bull,
Your penance at his alter, in the snow capped mounts,
Brought you a boon by which the whole world trembled.


Then your gaze shifted to the Mother Earth;
Whom you wanted to be under your very feet,
Sublime, submissive and at your service.


For your designs, you had at your service,
The master of cunning, deceit and sorcery
As the artful minister and henchman,
And of a soul sister whose beauty, a thousand poets would sing, and yet,
Who would spit fire through her eyes and venom through her words,
Bringing out the deep frustration against the prince
Who had scorned her nuanced advances.


The elders who fostered you, showed the way and yet disagreed and
Those ministers who advised against your avarice,
You packed them off into exile as senile;
That brother who would stand for righteousness,
You called a traitor and drove him out;
Another brother stands by you,
Silent but weeping within, knowing very well,
Where all these will lead one to.


The prince who had been exiled by deceit,
By stories cooked up by crooked minds,
And yet had left the throne for the forests,
Has embarked on his pilgrimage,
To reclaim what was snatched away from him,
When he was confused and in mourning,
After his father, had left this world, heart blown to pieces.


He has left his widowed and mourning mother
And all the counselors and Ministers behind.
On foot he has covered the entire stretch,
And reached the threshold of your fortress,
Where you have kept hostage, mother earth,


The prince has raised for his service,
A mighty army of little ones,
Who can riot or mutiny due to tender age,
But would not, due to his countenance.


That tiny messenger who came into your kingdom,
Elbowed the gate keeper and peeped into your court,
Looked you in the eyes and mocked at you,
You have caught, humiliated and imprisoned;
Using all powers that you and your chieftains could muster;
But know Mighty one, known to burn things down,
You have lit a flame to his wagging tail.


Mother Earth is not an inert being,
But a vibrant force, whose consort is the all mighty;
Her consent cannot be taken for granted or
Her patience thought not to wear out.


At her behest, the mighty army shall come,
It shall bring you to your knees,
Empty your head of the crowns worn with fanfare,
Even when you cowered mutely before mightier lords,
And with a shaft, the prince shall suck out of your heart,
That deeply set desire,
To lord over the Earth until humanity would last.


For, the Lord of this Universe,
Gives not a boon to torment;
And drench the earth with tears and blood,
But only to realize oneself.


So, realize now, or you are gone.

The prince or his troops may not burn you down,
But you will fall by the weight of your own deeds;
And sink into the deep trenches of history,
As a being who wasted a grandly taken boon,
And brought disrepute to those who stood by him.

 

 

-        Manimohan

  

 


Thursday, October 8, 2026

Before it is too late...let better sense prevail.

 



Thought is a river. If flows across ages and regions.

In India, in spite of various exploitations by Kings, Emperors and certain upper caste communities, in spite of invasions by the Mugals and the British, in spite of mis-governance by the Congress or the BJP, the life force of the Country continues to throb.  Sometimes, the pulse is very feeble, some times the throb becomes quite perceptible.

When after the Jalianwalah Bagh massacre, everything appeared to have been mowed down, there arose a storm.  It gathered momentum day by day and ultimately lead to the freedom of the country in 1947.

Then, the new rulers yoked to some dreams started their journey and in days and months to come became enamored by the belief that any thought process alien to theirs are against national interests.  State Governments not in line with the Center started to get dismissed.

Then, the party at the center itself got divided.  The pruning within the party saw to it that all regional satraps were cut to size.  In the ensuing hurry, the Queen felt extremely threatened and isolated and hence to put to rest the ghosts of her mind, imposed the Emergency.  

The next generation started its fight. Shanthi Bushan had already started it. Ramnath Goenka stood solidly as the real fourth pillar. Kuldip Nayar's pen showed the empire that pen was mightier than the gun. Jayaprakash Narayan took up the leadership. People like Kriplani and Fernandes were solidly with him.  The dark 19 months came to an end.




But the Janatha Party which came to power also followed in the foot steps of the Congress by dismissal of State Governments, not in line with their line of thought.  They also came down tumbling within months.

Again the Congress was back at the helm.  Mrs. Gandhi was assasinated and her son rose to power.  The methods used by those around, to achieve it were dubious.  The smoke still stinks.

But the newcomer wanted to have a fresh start. Deviating from the state run organisations, he preferred more of private participation. However, being aware of its perils, he intended to provide safeguards with the Consumer Protection Act.  But in a largely illiterate populace, such measures have not done much.  He also wanted computers to be brought in for the future.  A new era had started.

But, he again was pulled down by his over reach and treading on untested soil. The days after his defeat, again saw parties squabbling and throwing away the chance offered by the people to provide a better and fresh administration.

After the assassination of Rajiv, came the Narasimha Rao Government, which went further ahead with privatization and made whole sale purchase of elected MPs open, for its own survival.

There was again an opportunity for the opposition parties to come together to give an alternative.  The years with Vajpayee lead BJP were relatively stable and more people friendly.

But in the meanwhile, the seeds of enmity within the society had been sworn by the Rath yatra, undertaken purely only to overcome the dilemma in the face of Mandal Commission implementation by V P Singh.

It was also during the Vajpayee regime that the fire of Muslim animosity got ignited at Gujarat.  The very person who had jumped on the Rath had jumped to protect his protégée from the wrath of the Prime Minister himself on grounds of 'Raj Dharma'.

This, was subsequently to become his own nemeses.

After that period, there was a change in the course of history.  The Congress which had until then been on its own, had to depend upon regional parties and form a coalition at the Center. 

The UPA government was perceived to have reached a policy paralysis due to the pulling of different parties in different directions and the public perception that the regime had reached the nadir of corruption, saw to it that it was sent out.

Then came the new BJP regime.  It was not like the earlier one.  It came with an open Hindutva agenda.  The speeches of the leaders were always a war cry, against all historical enemies, whose progenies they tried to identify and fix in the present day India.  The consolidation of the Hindu community by identifying a common enemy was played to perfection.  In the process, hidden to the ordinary man's eyes, the corruption in the name of party fund mobilisation sky rocketed. Whenever there was a public murmur against the happenings, there was the bad boy Pakistan to be punished and taken to task.  Controls became centralised. Press conference by the highest elected representative became extinct. There were only monologues.

Elected representatives were bought outright.  On their joining the BJP, any case against them stood wiped off. Instead of dismissing elected state Governments, a new method had been discovered- take over.

Elections were seen to have been manipulated by use of EVMs which even the western countries were not seen to be using. A new generation of non-political activists started pointing out with data and instances of obvious manipulations of votes and the results. Also questions regarding certain defence deals were raised. The image of the BJP as a party with a difference and incorruptible was eroded in the public eye. (Of course only for those who wanted to see and did not have any coloured vision).  The new generation of activists also repeatedly emphasised how the basic structure of the Constitution was under challenge and how the ordinary citizen would suffer. That generation consisted of  #ArunShourie, #MedhaPatkar, #Yogendrayadav, #PrashanthBushan, and their likes.




To make election rigging more convenient, a new Act was brought in whereby the PM, HM (Or any other Minister) and LOP would constitute a select committee to decide on the CECs. The HM was replacement for the CJI which had been an interim arrangement. Obviously, the PM and HM would only decide. More State Governments were thrown out.  Then came an Intensive Revision of Electoral Rolls.  When large scale deletions in certain areas and large scale inclusions in some other areas were pointed out before the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the Court was not inclined to intervene.

There appeared to be an undeclared Emergency.  All organs of the Constitution, duty bound to safeguard the rights of the Citizens seem to be failing. The checks and balances were being thrown to the winds. It appeared quite obvious that the Executive, under the BJP, was keen to make Citizens of the Country who are supposed to be the real Monarchs of the Democracy, into subservient Subjects of the State.

The BJP wanted to increase the number of seats in the Lok Sabha by a delimitation exercise in such a manner that some of the areas of the Country would be cut to size, due to their reduced population in the last decades.  The punishment for having adhered sincerely to small family norms, was obviously because these areas with lesser growth rate of population and higher growth rate on economic index was also consisting of a larger population of literates and hence they were not able to send in representatives of the BJP, falling for their Hindutva mantra.  To create a smoke screen, this legislation was termed as a women's reservation bill, though women's reservation bill had already been passed separately much earlier and made into an Act itself.  

This measure failed.  The BJP has not been able to overcome that road block. Only after that they want to move on to 'One Nation One Election', so that with the entire election machinery under its complete control, the Supreme Court not likely to get disturbed over matters like voting rights because it has thought in it's wisdom that it was not a fundamental right and if some one could not vote today, they can always do it the next time and even otherwise hell will not break loose just because a few crores of the people cannot vote and have been removed from the electoral rolls, with one sweep, the entire machinery of governance in the Center and the States would be under its complete control.  There will not be the disturbance of one state election after the other, when the BJP will be compelled to hold back its agenda for the future. There will be a complete five year period when they can happily legislate as they like and as they have dreamt and all these new laws can be rolled out one after the other. And by the end of that five years, it could be decided what the polity and the Constitution should look like.

Then, as per the dream of the parivars, it will be the time for 'amrit kal' to start.  This will officially be the 'muhurth' when the Nation could be declared a Hindu Nation, and all those not Hindus shall be Minorities, may be with lesser rights, but certainly not entitled to the same rights as that of the Hindus because, this is essentially Hindustan and all those having allegiance to any other religion other than those of which had origin in this soil cannot demand equal rights.  

It was at this juncture that unfortunately a word came out of the mouth of the Hon'ble Chief Justice of India. He used the work 'Cockroaches' about people without any employment and hell bent on creating problems.  He has however later withdrawn it and said that he did not say it or mean it.  Whatever, it is, the hands of time had pulled the trigger.  He would have never imagined that cockroaches would proliferate only in those areas where filth is heaped up or swept under the carpet.

A Cockroach Janata Party was born on twitter and social media.  The underlying frustration of the young generation, got manifested by the support exhibited to the name and move.  The BJP started using everything under its control to press all panic buttons. The attempt to choke the fire only lead to more smoke emanating from it.

Then came the next trigger.  The NEET paper leak.  The younger generation which had been frustrated by the charades dished out on a daily basis on the economic and job front by the incumbent Government, came out to protest.  They demanded the resignation of the Education Minister.  It was only a token demand.  The real displeasure was against the entire Party.  But, by taking away one of the Key persons on fast, to a hospital, getting him dilute the demands, the BJP thought that it will have its way.  The youth showed unflinching resolve.  The Education Minister had to go.  

The new generation of activists had taken over.  They were #DhruvRathee, who had all along been exposing the false narratives of the BJP, #Zubair of the Alt news, the fact checker and the trio, #Abhijeet Dipke, #SauravDas and #NehaBora.

                                

This new generation has once again launched its next crusade.  This was triggered by the expose by The Indian Express regarding what was not fair in the EC.  

The data raising doubts had consistently been raised by the previous generation of activists like Dr. Parakala Prabakar Rao.  But, it was scoffed at, as claims by frustrated persons.  One other person who constantly called the farce was Dr. Subramaniam Swamy belonging to the BJP himself. 

True to its image and doing proud to #RamnathGoenka and #KuldipNayar, #TheIndianExpress, brought out details of the internal differences in the CEC and how, one of them overrode the objections of the other two.  It was because, he was his masters' man.  

Even as the Hon'ble Supreme Court has consented to get into the issue, there has been no time frame.  It is not clear whether the Court will be able to step over the immunity granted to the CEC by an Act of the Parliament.  Impeachment would be out of possibility given the resistance shown by the Chairmen of both houses in recent the past.

What is at stake is the essence of democracy. People have been forced to take to the streets.  The use of Police or paramilitary forces against public angst will not solve the problem.  It will lead to further disillusionment.  

The other mindless choice would be to employ thugs to oppose the public from assembling and showing their protest.  That will lead to chaos and civil strife.

Without waiting for matters to escalate, the CEC who is in the eye of the storm should resign.  The Act which was brought in after which appointments by the three member committee without CJI should be put on hold and the earlier interim arrangement should be brought back till a neutral selection team could be finalised.  All state elections where high level of deletions and additions have taken place (and also those places where numerous votes have been reported to have been polled even after the closing hours and at an impossible speed as pointed out by Mr. Parakala Prabhakar Rao) should be conducted again as per the pre-SIR electoral rolls (with strict adherence to verification of the voter id or other permissible documents to avoid illegal votes in the name of unavailable persons).  

The established political parties had been keeping a tight lipped silence in spite of repeated allegations of electoral frauds. Rahul Gandhi was the first to bite the bullet and openly declare 'Vote Chori'.  The other part of the political establishment still appears to be in a wait and watch mode.  They perhaps feel that the present system could be conducive to themselves, when they come to power or can part take of it. 

It is typically like the donkey withstanding all the blows, dreaming that one day the King will marry of the Princess to him.

So, before it is too late, let better sense prevail on the establishment and the established political forces of the country.




BELONGING - TO WHOM AND TO WHAT - PART 2

  A FAMILY UNDER CONSTANT THREAT AND FEAR We are all aware of the assassination of Mrs. Indira Gandhi and Mr. Rajiv Gandhi. We also rememb...