The
Supreme Court has held that ‘Access to internet by Children is a FundamentalRight under the Constitution.
Right to Education itself was upheld as a Fundamental Right and made a part of Right to Life as per the Judgement of the Supreme Court long ago and accordingly inserted as Article 21A. It was on the basis of the reasoned finding that without education (basic) a life with dignity was not possible.
However,
the 'Right to Vote' is not yet accepted as a Fundamental Right, by the Supreme
Court of India till date.
This
post intends to examine the issue:
Section 62 of ‘The
Representation of the People Act, 1951’ defines the Right to vote as below:
“62.
Right to vote.—
(1)No
person who is not, and except as expressly provided by this Act, every person
who is, for the time being entered in the electoral roll of any constituency
shall be entitled to vote in that constituency.
(2)No
person shall vote at an election in any constituency if he is subject to any of
the disqualifications referred to in section 16 of the Representation of the
People Act, 1950 (43 of 1950).
(3)No
person shall vote at a general election in more than one constituency of the
same class, and if a person votes in more than one such constituency, his votes
in all such constituencies shall be void.
(4)No
person shall at any election vote in the same constituency more than once,
notwithstanding that his name may have been registered in the electoral roll
for the constituency more than once, and if he does so vote, all his votes in
that constituency shall be void.
(5)No
person shall vote at any election if he is confined in a prison, whether under
a sentence of imprisonment or transportation or otherwise, or is in the lawful
custody of the police:
Provided
that nothing in this sub-section shall apply to a person subjected to
preventive detention under any law for the time being in force.
Provided
further that by reason of the prohibition to vote under this sub-section, a
person whose name has been entered in the electoral roll shall not cease to be
an elector.
(6)Nothing
contained in sub-sections (3) and (4) shall apply to a person who has been
authorised to vote as proxy for an elector under this Act in so far as he votes
as a proxy for such elector.”
Now, what if a person does not have a
vote, other than due to any of the exclusions in the above Section?
The present dispute regarding the
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) is a case in point.
Though the SIR has been conducted in
earlier regimes also, the present exercise has been subjected to disputes for a
variety of reasons.
The
statutory authority for the Election Commission to conduct a revision of the
Voter List, flows out of the following provisions of ‘The Representation Of The
People Act, 1950’ :
“Section 21. Preparation
and revision of electoral rolls.—
(1)The
electoral roll for each constituency shall be prepared in the prescribed manner
by reference to the qualifying date and shall come into force immediately upon
its final publication in accordance with the rules made under this Act.
(2)The
said electoral roll—
(a)shall,
unless otherwise directed by the Election Commission for reasons to be recorded
in writing, be revised in the prescribed manner by reference to the qualifying
date—(i)before
each general election to the House of the People or to the Legislative Assembly
of a State; and(ii)before
each bye-election to fill a casual vacancy in a seat allotted to the
constituency; and
(b)shall
be revised in any year in the prescribed manner by reference to the qualifying
date if such revision has been directed by the Election Commission:
Provided
that if the electoral roll is not revised as aforesaid, the validity or
continued operation of the said electoral roll shall not thereby be affected.
(3)Notwithstanding
anything contained in sub-section (2), the Election Commission may at any time,
for reasons to be recorded, direct a special revision of the electoral roll for
any constituency or part of a constituency in such manner as it may think fit:
Provided
that subject to the other provisions of this Act, the electoral roll for the
constituency, as in force at the time of the issue of any such direction, shall
continue to be in force until the completion of the special revision so
directed.
Section 22. Correction of entries in electoral
rolls.—
If the electoral registration officer for a constituency, on application
made to him or on his own motion, is satisfied after such inquiry as he thinks
fit, that any entry in the electoral roll of the constituency—
(a)is erroneous or defective in any particular,
(b)should be transposed to another place in the roll
on the ground that the person concerned has changed his place of ordinary
residence within the constituency, or
(c)should be detected on the ground that the person
concerned is dead or has ceased to be ordinarily resident in the constituency
or is otherwise not entitled to be registered in that roll, the electoral
registration officer shall, subject to such general or special direction, if
any, as may be given by the Election Commission in this behalf, amend,
transpose or delete the entry after proper verification of facts in such manner
as may be prescribed:
Provided that before taking any action on any ground under clause (a) or
clause (b) or any action under clause (c) on the ground that the person
concerned has ceased to be ordinarily resident in the constituency or that he
is otherwise not entitled to be registered in the electoral roll of that
constituency, the electoral registration officer shall give the person
concerned a reasonable opportunity of being heard in respect of the action
proposed to be taken in relation to him after proper verification of facts in
such manner as may be prescribed.”
The state-wise data
regarding additions and deletions through the current SIR is as below (Source: https://www.newsclick.in/exclusive-sir-probe-how-many-voters-did-eci-really-disenfranchise)
The
investigation by the Internet Freedom foundation reveals how these ‘logicaldiscrepancies have arisen:
“The
deletions and notices do not occur evenly partly due to how the software reads
names which are the data entries. The transliteration engine's failures are
systematic rather than random. "Xalxo", the spelling used by the
Oraon community, was rendered "Khalkho" and flagged, Md and Mohammed,
Sk and Sheikh, and Chattopadhyay and Chatterjee were treated as distinct
persons. Each such mismatch between an elector's name, or a parent's name, and
the digitised roll surfaces either as an unmapped entry or as a logical
discrepancy of the parent-name kind, and therefore as a notice.”
The
Wire in its report under the heading ‘In West Bengal, SIR Hearing Notices Surgein Muslim-Majority Districts’ dated 14.01.2026, states as below:
‘..the
release of the Draft Roll and Absentee, Shifted, Suspected Dead (ASSD) list
sparked resentment in Matua and other Hindu Scheduled Caste localities. These
communities were hit heavily by deletions and no-mapping, due to which the
narrative backfired. In recent weeks, however, the administrative focus appears
to have shifted, through the SIR hearing process, towards minority-heavy
Polling Stations (PS).’
‘In
The Wire’s earlier constituency-level reading of the SIR draft rolls, “No
Mapping” emerged as a key pressure point. Voters who could not be linked to the
2002 roll, the legacy anchor in the SIR 2025 framework, were effectively pushed
into a higher-risk verification pathway. But the analysis also produced an
inconvenient statistical outcome for BJP’s “infiltration” propaganda.
Muslim-majority constituencies appeared among the most consistently mapped and,
therefore, among the most documented. In Murshidabad, for instance, Domkal
(77.67% minority population) showed just 0.42% No Mapping, while Raninagar
(75.40% minority) recorded 0.91%, Hariharpara (74.96% minority) 0.60%, and
Lalgola (77.29% minority) 1.1%.
Yet
the district-wise hearing numbers reviewed by The Wire tell a sharply different
story. Across districts, the share of voters called for hearings climbs steeply
with the Muslim population share. Statistical analysis of the dataset shows a
strong positive correlation between a district’s Muslim population percentage
and the percentage of electors called for hearing per constituency, with a
correlation coefficient of 0.79. In practical terms, this implies that
approximately 62% of the variation in hearing-call rates across districts can
be explained by Muslim population density alone.
The
implication is stark: even where Muslims appear highly “mapped” (low No
Mapping), Muslim-heavy districts still show the highest hearing intensity,
suggesting the system driving voters into hearings is not primarily No Mapping,
but other triggers such as “logical discrepancies”, duplicates and name-related
mismatches, especially those amplified by script conversion and rigid matching
rules.’
In
this context, the provisions of the Constitution require to be viewed:
Article 325 of the Constitution of India
mandates that “there shall be one general electoral roll for every territorial
constituency for elections to Parliament or State Legislatures, and no person
can be excluded from or granted a special electoral roll based solely on
religion, race, caste, or sex”.
Thus,
any exclusion on the basis of religion, race or caste, is strictly
Unconstitutional.
Now,
let us come to the question of completion of the appellate proceedings under
the Principles of Natural Justice.
The appeals against
deletion from the voters list is governed by the Section 24 of ‘The
Representation of Peoples Act, 1950’, which reads as below:
“Section
24. Appeals.—
An appeal shall lie within such time and in such manner as may be
prescribed.--(a)to the magistrate or additional district magistrate or executive
magistrate or district collector or an officer of equivalent rank, from any
order of the electoral registration officer under section 22 or section 23(b)to the chief electoral officer, from any order of
the district magistrate or the additional district magistrate under clause (a).”
Now, as long as the above said
procedure of appeal has not been completed, the action set out in Section 22 of
the said Act is not yet complete and therefore as per the Provisio to Sub
Section 3 of Section 21 of the said Act, “the
electoral roll for the constituency, as in force at the time of the issue of
any such direction, shall continue to be in force until the completion of the
special revision so directed”.
In respect of WB, as
per The Hindu report, 38.31 lakh appeals had been filed before the tribunals as
per ECI This in spite of the ECI stating that
only 27 lakhs were deleted due to ‘logical discrepancies’.
However as per
reports by an investigation by the Internet Freedom foundation, ‘Behind the
deletions lay a larger suspect population, the logical-discrepancy software
flagged 1.31 crore electors in West Bengal and 2.35 crore in Madhya Pradesh,
17.11% and 41.22% of those electorates, and West Bengal's count fell to about
95 lakh within weeks as the rules were modified mid-exercise.’
As per reports in the Times of India, out
of the above appeals, only about 1,26,194 could be decided as in September 2026
(much after the elections have been completed in May 2026) and out of that 93%
appeals have been decided in favour of the appellants and have been re-instated
in the voter list.
The
remaining appeals are pending.
Thus when the appeal proceedings are
pending, the voter list could not be considered as final and therefore the
voter list that existed prior to the SIR ought to have been the basis on which
elections should have happened.
But, unfortunately, in spite of a litigation before
the Supreme Court, this did not happen.
It is in this context that the question
arises as to whether ‘Right to Vote’ is a Fundamental Right under the
Constitution or not. News reports state
that the Supreme Court has held that it is not a Fundamental Right.
Article 21 of
the Constitution of India reads as below:
“21.
Protection of life and personal liberty
No
person shall be deprived of his life or personal liberty except according to
procedure established by law.”
In the landmark judgment Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978), Supreme Court held that the right to life and personal liberty under Article 21 is not limited to mere animal existence but includes the right to live with dignity. The court emphasized that the procedure established by law must be fair, just, and reasonable, and it cannot be arbitrary, oppressive, or unreasonable.
In the
case of Subramanian Swamy vs Union of India, (WP (CRIMINAL) No. 184 OF
2014) Supreme Court held that ‘Right to reputation is an insegregable part of
Article 21 of the Constitution. A person’s reputation is an inseparable element
of an individual’s personality and it cannot be allowed to be tarnished and
that the right to reputation is an inherent right guaranteed by Article 21’.
In The
Cochin Institute Of Science And ... vs Jisin Jijo The Kerala High Court in
its judgement dated 4 June, 2019 held that ‘the fundamental right to life under
Article 21 encompasses the right of an individual to make choices and take
decisions impacting the evolution of the individual.’ In doing so the High Court placed reliance
upon the judgement of the Supreme Court in Puttasamy case where it had been laid
down that ‘The freedoms under Article 19 can be fulfilled where the individual
is entitled to decide upon his or her preferences. Read in conjunction with
Article 21, liberty enables the individual to have a choice of preferences on
various facets of life including what and how one will eat, the way one will
dress, the faith one will espouse and a myriad other matters on which autonomy
and self-determination require a choice to be made within the privacy of the
mind.”
The News Click in its report dated 22.06.2026 states as below:
“In
West Bengal and Bihar alone, the state governments –elected on the basis of
this faultily implemented SIR–have simply announced –without policy discussion
or judicial scrutiny –that the ‘new voters lists’ will be regarded as the final
electoral list and linked this to welfare programmes. Both states are now ruled
by the extreme right Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), a political behemoth that
has –in close collusion with a non-transparent Election Commission of India
(ECI) been a “beneficiary” of this SIR process.
Put
clearly, if a person’s name is removed from the voter list, their ration card
is deactivated, monthly cash transfers are stopped, and even their bank
accounts face cancellation. There are also local reports of the possibility of
unilateral deletion from agricultural land records, especially if you are a
disenfranchised voter from Murshidabad and Malda, Muslim majority districts!
This policy effectively treats a deleted voter as someone who has lost their
official status as a citizen without the final adjudication of their
citizenship status.”
Depriving someone of the right to vote and
exclusion from the voters list, could deprive them the very right to exist as a
citizen and get any benefits from the Government schemes, which directly
impacts their life as well as that of their children, could create a stigma in
the eyes of others, as if they are illegal immigrants, as if they have fudged
their records earlier, as if their exercising the right to vote earlier was by
reasons of fraud or forgery or misstatement and consequently causes irreparable
damage to their reputation and also the right to dignity which are enshrined in
the Article 21 of the Constitution as has been upheld by the Supreme Court
itself.
Further, as pointed out by the
Kerala High Court in the Jisin Jijio case, when the citizens have a right of
choice under Article 21 read with Article 19, denial of the right to vote,
unless as per the reasons set out in The Representation of Peoples Act, would
tantamount to denial of the right to choose ones representative and as a
consequence the Government and directly impacts ‘the
right of an individual to make choices and take decisions impacting the
evolution of the individual’.
If the Supreme Court is not able to see through
these, the stature of the Highest Court would be sullied as warned by Justice
V.R.Krishna Iyer as below:
"One
day the people of this country will rise and say that we don't want this
magnificent red stone edifice on the Curson Road because it is seen to be
counterproductive and in turn the High Courts."